trisha
Female
http://justanotheropinion.uber.com
Community

most popular posts

worth reading

For updates and new blog posts please subscribe

RSS Feed
May 31, 2008 3:23 PM  (go back to main view)
another stupid christian fundamentalist argument

up until last year I had never once heard this saying. Now I can't seem to go a week without hearing some arrogant talk-show host or holier-than-thou preacher glibly using it in an attempt to ridicule and demean rational thinkers.

I must admit that when I first heard it, I was perplexed. I guess I don't have an ear for fundamentalist double-speak. I later learned that it's basically a cute way of saying, "You may not believe in God today, but someday you will. Oh, and (wink, wink) by then it will be too late."Apart from the implicit threat of Hell and eternal damnation that's present in many of these fundamentalist credos, this one contains a strange and obvious admission of one of theism's most glaring sources of embarrassment: the direct correlation between faith and fear, between the promise of a comforting afterlife and the harsh reality of this life, between belief in God and ignorance of the natural world.

Here is a perfectly acceptable translation of this ridiculous little homily: "You can't be an atheist forever. One day, at a moment of extreme personal anguish or loss of self-control, when you are stressed or scared, cowering in fear of the unknown or of impending death, then you will turn to God. You will seek out His comfort, you will use Him as a crutch to get you through. His loving mercy will be like a warm blanket wrapped around your shivering body."

Well, well. Humans seek comfort in stressful situations. There's a shocker. Atheists, I think, have a better-than-average understanding of this type of human fallibility. It is, in fact, one of the primary reasons we reject human inventions, particularly those that seek to assuage the fear of death or the unknown. It is therefore quite perplexing to me when one of the primary arguments against the existence of God is turned around and used, unwittingly, by a devout theist in an attempt to ridicule atheism. But this is exactly what these poor misguided fools are doing. It's as clear as if they'd rented a loud speaker and pulpit and plopped down in the middle of Central Park shouting, "Religion is for the stressed and weak-minded! God is real only to those who are cowering in fear!" Somehow, I doubt this is the message they want to be sending, and yet they send it over and over and over again.

And I know from personally experience. my dad was in the hospital last December for pneumonia. he was in really bad shape, his kidneys were shutting down, and for a while I was convinced that he wasn't going to make it. not once did I every think about the possible existence of god. (and if anyone cares my dads doing great, he's alot more happier and care free after his near- death experience.)

So the popularity of this little saying among the devoutly religious strikes me as a bit curious. And let's be honest: even if all atheists renounced their atheism upon their deathbeds or at the deathbeds of loved ones (ludicrous, of course, but let's go with the flow for a moment), what does that prove other than the obvious point that these people were human? Faced with unimaginable anguish or adversity, a human being sought comfort in a fairy tale. Understandable? Of course. Healthy? Perhaps. Proof of God's existence? Um, no. As a matter of fact, it goes a long way to proving exactly the opposite: God exists only in the minds of frightened and fallible human beings.

So whenever anyone, with an air of glib superiority, makes absurd generalizations about the unwillingness of free-thinkers to take up residence in man-made dirt ditches, I politely tell them, first, that they are just plain wrong; and second, even if they believe they are right, the analogy is so thoroughly counterproductive to their cause that it might behoove them to pick a better one.I'm pretty sure the devoutly religious have better things to do than lay bare, for all the world to see, one of the most convincing arguments for atheism.

Post Tags:
Related Posts:
Hilarious Joke(Today - No Comments)
Further Proof Of Evolution(Today - No Comments)
Serial killer In The Making(5 days ago - 1 Comment)
Zeitgeist II Addendum(5 days ago - No Comments)
Blog Comments (8):
Posted by Jules on April 23, 2008 8:20 PM
Wow - great thoughts. I completely agree with it all! While I do often feel the need to proclaim my dislike and thoughts of absurdity in regard to religion and theists, I try to avoid it as much as possible. I am an Atheist and my mom said that when I am older, I will believe in God because I do not understand it all right now. I basically said that I understood it when I was 5 and thought it was ridiculous then as well. There is no way in Hell (or any other mythical place created by religion) that I ever be religious, or buy into any religious/Christian business bullshit, or any religion for that matter. I talked to my boss about it too, he is really cool, but he said that my mom was right. He said that I would become more “spiritual” as I grow older. HA Also, many people jump to the conclusion that I am going through hard times and have somehow “lost” God. That is really common and angers me quite a bit. I should probably start asking them why they “lost” Santa Claus along the way just because they stopped receiving presents from him. Eventually, people have to grow out of believing absurd things, yet somehow, theists never seem to grow out of the most significant hoax of their life.
Posted by TheWaterSc... on April 22, 2008 6:04 AM
People who say these things are going against their own faith, and nine times out of ten they have non-religious motives like money or the desire to mess with people who are smarter than they are. Either that or they're just plain looney tunes. Either way, if you take one look at the average fundamentalist community in this country, you'll see just how good and holy they really are. It's people like that who drive others AWAY from God because nobody wants to end up like them.
Posted by trisha on April 21, 2008 7:21 PM
thank you guys for the comments.
I absolutely agree with you guys. :)
Posted by juggalosau... on April 21, 2008 5:07 PM
I completely agree. Nice blog :)
Posted by Richard Po... on April 21, 2008 4:29 PM
I think that Catholicism got lost somewhere after the Romans decided to use it as a political tool. The distortion of religion for political gain is as old as prostitution. Don’t mean to offend anybody by that, I’m trying to make a point... and certainly in this day and age the church is getting desperate. As for myself, I’m very religious... I pray every day and believe in a higher power, but it has nothing to do with God or the church. I believe we’re all linked in someway and as a whole we’re capable of incredible things... and horrible things as well. I think that if we just start by respecting each other and our planet we might just get somewhere. Instead of fighting and competing to see who has the biggest dick.
Posted by JessiCan on April 21, 2008 3:54 AM
agreed! thanks for the friend request...I want to read more of your posts!
Posted by screenplay... on April 20, 2008 10:48 PM
Thoughtful post. My personal take is that religion is, in part, the human animal's adaptation to being sentient and, in turn, lugging around the realization that one day they'll be no more. That heavy sh*t can mess a brother/sister up, so religion serves as a (very complex, surprisingly dangerous) coping mechanism. However, it's easier to believe in an entirely non-fact supported construct if everyone else does so the one's with the most radical beliefs are the ones who spend the most time trying to seek converts...or something like that.
Posted by cassie on April 20, 2008 12:19 PM
I hate when others try to impose religion and basically say - if you don't believe you will burn.. I think all religion is the same and the lack of religion too. Pretty much, whether you be a Jew, Catholic, Atheist, Buddhist.. whatever... the point of all of it - is to try and be a good person while you're alive.. don't kill anyone, don't be spiteful... all that. In the end, no matter where we believe we'll end up or just rot in the dirt - it only matters what we intended while we were here. So all you people who believe I'm going to rot in Hell.. I feel sorry for you - you can't be accepting of others' beliefs.. and fyi, I'm Catholic.
RSS Feed
Add a comment
Guests
Name
E-mail
Uber Members
E-mail
Password
Flash Is Loading
Oct 10, 2008 12:22 PM
hii thanks for the add :)
great blog!
Oct 06, 2008 1:22 AM
Thanks for the comment on my page.
Looking forward to reading your blog as well.
Sep 26, 2008 11:49 PM
hey love the post on "jesus sucks"
haha.
anyway since uber is closing.
i hope to keep in contact.
add me @ myspace.com/bitch aroostar
xoxo
Sep 25, 2008 1:43 AM
Hi there!
Really? they'll gonna shut it down? my gosh! : (
Sep 16, 2008 10:25 PM
Hi there trisha ;>!
Sep 16, 2008 5:52 PM
You web is awesome. Makes me think about stuff.
Sep 09, 2008 1:27 PM
hey, whats up? i love your default pic of your puppy! so cuute! <333
MC
Aug 05, 2008 9:08 PM
Hi :) thanks for the request, how are you doing? beautiful dog
Aug 05, 2008 3:10 PM
well hello, i love ur page! how u doing today?
Glo
Aug 03, 2008 12:43 PM
hi! thnx for the add!!!
-glo
Aug 02, 2008 11:38 AM
Hi Trish!
Love your counter!
Did you ever heard of The Brights?
Find us at www.the-brights.n et/
Jul 31, 2008 4:31 AM
Thanks for the add,
I dig the blogs
Jul 30, 2008 8:55 PM
uh thanks. I was reading your blogs..very interesting..- i liked the 'dress jesus up' thing - funny
Jul 30, 2008 7:10 PM
I'm great,thanks :)
it is your dog?
Comment: